Read in the Substack app
Open app

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Peter E's avatar

Battery swapping was possibly viable when charging speeds were low. Now I drive for two hours, get a coffee and use the toilets while the car gets another 100 miles of range. There are far more 24/7 charging locations then there will ever be battery swap locations and there will never be a situation when there are no charged batteries to be swapped. We have a charging infrastructure. Where is the battery swapping infrastructure?

Expand full comment
Md Nadim Ahmed's avatar

# On Battery Swapping: Where It Works and Where It Doesn't

I remain skeptical of battery swapping for passenger cars. NIO's finances appear dire, and while CATL might invest heavily—hoping to corner the market through platform standardization—the economics remain questionable. Swap stations are simply too expensive.

Battery swapping makes perfect sense for 2/3 wheelers. Small batteries mean cheap swap stations, local networks can scale gradually, and these vehicles rarely need highway infrastructure. The model has already taken off across Asian markets—India, Indonesia, and Taiwan.

Commercial trucking presents another viable application. Downtime carries high opportunity costs, making swap stations economically justified. In Australia, given our vast distances and the world's largest trucks, this model seems inevitable.

Mining trucks targeting full electrification within ten years remain an open question—whether through battery swapping or high-speed charging is unclear.

What's your view on overhead charging cables for highways? Europe and India are trialling them for commercial trucks. Are there Chinese experiments worth noting?

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts